Same-Sex Desire in the Old West

Oldwestminersdance.jpg

Print from the article “Pioneer Mining in California” in The Century Magazine, May 1891

Sexual and gender nonconformity lay at the heart of the Old West. A mining camp description from 1852 says, “Dancing parties such as these [all-male miners' dances] were very common, especially in small camps.”[1]

A “Mrs. Nash” served ten years as laundress with Custer's Seventh Calvary.[2] When she died in 1878 her male sex was discovered. Her third soldier-husband killed himself over the resulting ridicule he faced from fellow soldiers.

And in California, in 1876, Jeanne Bonnet (a reputed “man hater”) was killed by a hail of bullets through her bedroom window.[3] She was in bed awaiting her bedmate Blanche Beunon who was busy undressing. Guilty fingers pointed to Beunon's jilted male lover.

Sources

1. Peter Boag, Re-Dressing America's Frontier Past (Berkeley: University of California, 2011), 214 n. 7.

2. Boag, 130.

3. Boag, 35.