Angela "Angie" Calomiris: August 1, 1916 - January 30, 1995

From OutHistory
Jump to navigationJump to search

Adapted from Wikipedia, accessed November 8, 2011.


Angela "Angie" Calomiris was an American photographer and a lesbian who became a secret FBI informant within the Communist Party USA (CPUSA) under the name Angela Cole. Calomiris spent seven years undercover in the party from February 1942 until April 26, 1949 when she was called to testify in the trial of eleven CPUSA leaders, who were convicted of conspiracy to advocate the overthrow of the US government on October 13, 1949.

Her private life as a lesbian is of relevance, most directly, because of her dating Myrtis Johnson, the sister-in-law of her FBI handler, Ken Bierly. But her membership in a stigmatized group, homosexuals, and her informing against a stigmatized group, communists, suggests a more complex connection between the personal and political, as does her informing on a communist lesbian policewoman and another woman, who then lost their jobs.[1]

Early life

The daughter of Greek immigrants, Calomiris was born in New York City on August 1, 1916 and grew up on the Lower East Side of Manhattan.[2]

Her father was a furrier who lost his job during the Great Depression and was forced to support his family through menial labor.[3]

Calomiris attended Brooklyn College and Hunter College of the City University of New York for two years, and decided to become a professional photographer, having fallen in love with photography as a child.[4]

After her studies, she took up residence in Greenwich Village and "instead of buying food, she saved money to buy a camera". She also joined the Photo League, a group of amateur photographic enthusiasts, which included a number of communists among its members.[5]

FBI Informant

In February 1942, Calomiris was approached by two FBI agents, who asked her if she would be willing to infiltrate the CPUSA as an informant. The agents told her that she would receive neither money nor glory for her work, and that she would be disavowed if discovered, possibly putting her in personal danger, but Calomiris accepted their offer anyway after a week of deliberation.[6]

When asked in 1950 about her decision to inform, Calomiris told the New York Times that she accepted the offer because she "kind of wanted to be a hero."[7]

Her FBI handlers advised her to "never act conspiratorially or try to pry into party secrets", but rather to simply gather and report whatever information came her way.

A few weeks after meeting with the FBI in 1942, Calomiris attended a lecture about Soviet efforts in World War II, where she was recruited by communist organizers.[8]

She then agreed to join the party, but was advised by her communist recruiters that she should take an assumed name for security reasons and chose the name Angela Cole. Calomiris then rose quickly through the ranks of the party by volunteering for jobs that no one else wanted to do.[9]

Over her time in the party, she served as educational director, branch organizer, and co-section organizer of the West Midtown Branch of the CPUSA, before rising to the position of finance secretary.[10]

As finance secretary, Calomiris had access to extensive information on party members, including the real names of all members of the branch and the leaders of the national party, and passed all of this information to the FBI.[11]

Throughout the time that Calomiris served as an informant, she supported herself as a professional photographer, specializing in animal photographs, but the FBI also paid her a salary (a fact which Calomiris later denied) and covered her expenses, including Communist Party dues.[12]

Foley Square trial

During World War II, the US Department of Justice avoided prosecuting American communists, to avoid antagonizing the Soviet Union, then a military ally. After the end of the war, the Justice Department began compiling a case against the leadership of the CPUSA, using evidence from informants, including Calomiris.

July 20, 1948

John McGohey, the US Attorney for the Southern District of New York, was given the lead role in prosecuting the cases and, under the Smith Act, presented charges against twelve communist leaders on July 20, 1948. The defendants were then indicted by a grand jury and arrested.[13]

After the arrests, Calomiris remained undercover, and continued her activities within the Party. When the trial of the communist leaders began in January, she travelled to Washington, DC to join a protest against the prosecutions. She also donated $50 in government money to the legal defense fund for the defendants, and was asked to help plan their legal strategy, but refused.[14]

April 26, 1949

During the trial, the prosecution decided to use Calomiris as a surprise witness and on April 26, she "stunned" the defendants by taking the stand for the prosecution.[15]

In her testimony, Calomiris identified four of the defendants, John Williamson, Benjamin J. Davis, Robert G. Thompson, and Gilbert Green as members of the Communist Party and provided information on its organization. She also testified that the Party espoused violent revolution against the government and that the Party had attempted to recruit members working in key war industries, on instructions from Moscow.[16]

Calomiris was then cross-examined so harshly by the defense, that the presiding judge Harold Medina rebuked the defense attorney, but the questioning "failed to shake her testimony."[17]

Around the time of the trial, Calomiris also began dating Myrtis Johnson, the sister-in-law of her FBI handler, Ken Bierly, a fact that attracted attention from the media.[18]

Celebrity after the trial: October 13, 1949

The defendants in the Foley Square trial were convicted on October 13, 1949, and Calomiris became a minor celebrity as the result of her role in the proceedings.

Autobiography, 1950


She capitalized on the fame by writing an autobiography, Red Masquerade: Undercover for the FBI, which was published by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins in 1950.

George Scharsburg of the Chicago Daily Tribune wrote that the book was "well worth reading".[19]

A.H. Raskin of the New York Times praised it for being "as interesting for its insight into the problems that best a Government 'plant' in the party as it is for the light it throws on the jealousies, personal intrigues and divisions that exist behind the party's monolithic facade".[20]

But Richard Donnelly criticized the book in The Yale Law Journal for being "rather pretentious".[21]

After the publication of her book, Calomiris went on a number of talk radio shows, appearing most notably on former first lady Eleanor Roosevelt's show on NBC, Today with Mrs. Roosevelt, where Roosevelt praised Calomiris as "a young lady of great courage."[22]

During the same period, Calomiris continued to work with the FBI, providing information on a communist lesbian policewoman named Yetta Cohn, which resulted in the firing of Cohn and another woman.[23]

Later life

Calomiris's celebrity status soon began to evaporate, and a number of potential television and movie projects fell through as did offers of a photography job.

Calomiris broke up with Myrtis Johnson, and fell out with many of her friends in the New York lesbian community, who disapproved of her decision to give the FBI information on Cohn.[24]

Calomiris then left New York, opening a bed and breakfast in Provincetown, Massachusetts in the 1960s.[25]

She died on January 30, 1995 in San Miguel de Allende, Mexico.[26]

See also: F.B.I. and Homosexuality: A History


  1. Lisa Davis, "The FBI's Lesbian, Eleanor Roosevelt, and Other Tales from the Red Scare, Rethinking Marxism, volume 21, issue 4, October 2009, p. 625
  2. Veronica Wilson, James Gilbert Ryan, Leonard Schlup, editors, Historical Dictionary of the 1940s, London: M.E. Sharpe, 2006, page 64.
  3. M.H. Mahoney, Women in Espionage: A Biographical Dictionary, ABC-CLIO, Santa Barbara, California, 1993, page 37
  4. Wilson citing Harvey Breit, "Talk with Miss Calomiris", The New York Times, November 26, 1950, page BR9.
  5. Mahoney, page 37.
  6. Mahoney, pp. 37–38
  7. Breit
  8. Mahoney, p. 38
  9. Mahoney, p. 39
  10. Richard Donnelly, "Judicial Control of Informants, Spies, Stool Pigeons, and Agent Provocateurs", The Yale Law Journal, volume 60, number 7. November 1951, page 1124
  11. Mahoney page 39
  12. Russell Porter, "Witness Swears Communists Set Up Wallace Party in 1947", The New York Times, May 3, 1949, page 3. Russell Porter, "Girl Aide of FBI Testifies of 7 Years as Communist", The New York Times, April 27, 1949, page 1. Lisa Davis, "The FBI's Lesbian, Eleanor Roosevelt, and Other Tales from the Red Scare, Rethinking Marxism, volume 21, issue 4, October 2009, pages 624–625
  13. Michael Belknap, Cold War Political Justice, Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1977, page 51.
  14. "FBI Informer Tells of Plea", The Baltimore Sun, May 4, 1949, page 4}}
  15. Joseph Hearst, "Girl Official of Party Stuns Reds at Trial", Chicago Daily Tribune, April 27, 1949, page 21
  16. Russell Porter, "Communist Drive in Industry Bared", The New York Times, April 29, 1949, page 11.
  17. Russell Porter, "Witness Parries Red Trial Thrusts", The New York Times, April 30, 1949, page 6.
  18. Davis, p. 625
  19. George Scharsburg, "Her 7 Year Masquerade As a Communist for FBI" The Chicago Daily Tribune, page 14, November 5, 1950.
  20. A. H. Raskin, "The F.B.I. Planted Her There", The New York Times, November 19, 1950, page BR2.
  21. Donnelly
  22. "Davis, p. 623"
  23. Davis, p. 630
  24. Davis, pp. 630-631
  25. "Davis, p. 623"
  26. Wilson, p. 65


Calomiris, Angela. Red Masquerade. 1950

Davis, Lisa E. "Undercover Girl -- The FBI's Lesbian: A Note on Resources." CLAGS News. Summer 2003/Vol. XIII, No. 2, page 8.

Tucker, Ann. The Photo League, 1936-1951. 1957.

[,+1945-63%22&source=bl&ots=MGG5V_Ziys&sig=dNibTtZ4YbyGv2ACdqv0KtJMWno&hl=en&sa=X&ei=xXP4TqvWNLGnsQLVjp3cAQ&sqi=2&ved=0CCgQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=%22Gender%20and%20Political%20Subversion%20During%20the%20Cold%20War%2C%201945-63%22&f=false Wilson, Veronica. Angela Calomiris.] In: Historical dictionary of the 1940s edited by James Gilbert Ryan, Leonard C. Schlup. Armonk (N.Y.) ; London : M.E. Sharpe, copyright 2006.

Wilson, Veronica. “Red Masquerades: Gender and Political Subversion During th Cold War, 1945-1963”, Ph.D diss. Rutegers University, 2002.