Richard J. Rosendall
How We Won Marriage Equality in Washington, DC
March 3, 2010 marked the start of same-sex couples being able to apply for marriage licenses in District of Columbia Superior Court.
The seeds of this victory trace back to 1975, when Cade Ware, Frank Kameny, and Craig Howell of the Gay Activists Alliance (as it was then called) gave the first testimony before the DC Council in favor of same-sex marriage. Philip Pannell, long a leading voice in DC’s black gay community, testified for marriage equality in 1976. In 1978 – responding to Anita Bryant’s successful anti-gay campaign in Dade County, Florida the previous year – Jim Zais, Mayo Lee, and Bill Boggan launched an effort to bar DC ballot measures in which people would vote on other people’s rights. This effort succeeded when Arrington Dixon, who pledged his support during his campaign for DC Council Chair that year, pushed through legislation as chair in 1979 barring any referendum or initiative that “authorizes, or would have the effect of authorizing, discrimination prohibited under Chapter 14 of Title 2....”
Our long journey to equality included everything from Human Rights Act protections to sodomy law repeal. But it was not just policy victories that brought us here. Gay folk of all colors and backgrounds have deep roots in Washington. We have helped build and enrich our communities. Our opponents underestimated the strength of those roots, crying "Let the people vote!" as if the people had not elected our overwhelmingly pro-gay legislature.
Among current activists, I must single out Bob Summersgill, our principal strategist, whose mastery of District law and the legislative process were invaluable. He devised the incremental approach that began with domestic partnerships and led to the moment last year when marriage was simply the next logical step rather than a giant leap.
As with any successful bill, there are legislators to thank. The top honors go to David Catania, author of the bill; Phil Mendelson, who steered it through committee; and DC Council Chairman Vincent Gray. Mayor Adrian Fenty, before signing the bill, invoked the moral example of his parents and spoke of a city that embraces all its people. Staffers are generally unsung, but they are essential. Here the stalwarts include Catania’s chief of staff, Ben Young; and Mendelson’s legislative counsel, Brian Moore. Moore made the committee report a work of art.
We did not just focus on passing the law; we laid the groundwork to sustain the victory. It was a multi-faceted effort. DC Clergy United for Marriage Equality, co-chaired by Pastors Dennis Wiley, Christine Wiley, and Rob Hardies, organized a broad spectrum of affirming clergy. DC Attorney General Peter Nickles strongly defended the bill against proposed ballot measures. Brian Flowers provided legal expertise as General Counsel to the D.C. Council. Further legal chops were provided by Mark Levine, counsel for the Gertrude Stein Democratic Club, and by Nancy Polikoff, Michele Zavos, and the National Center for Lesbian Rights. Michael Crawford of DC for Marriage led a grassroots organizing effort. Nick McCoy did extensive voter canvassing; he and Rev. Monique Ellison led outreach efforts at community meetings around the city. Sultan Shakir of the Human Rights Campaign assisted in organizing the Campaign for All D.C. Families. Republicans Patrick Mara and Bob Kabel lobbied Congress urging them not to interfere. I haven’t room to mention all who contributed.
The hundreds of witnesses at the legislative hearings last fall, representing the diversity of the city’s population, broke heavily in favor of the bill. We told about our lives and our families, while our opponents focused on dogma and fear-mongering.
Any student of the civil rights movement knows that the march to victory is interrupted by plenty of internal squabbling. In DC we were blessed by community leaders who were determined to keep our eyes on the prize. This was aided by the fact that our coalition was decades in the making.
Our opponents in Congress will likely push for an amendment to the DC appropriations bill blocking expenditures to implement the law. Before then, we will have several months of same-sex couples obtaining marriage licenses. They will serve as living, breathing rebuttals of the horrors conjured by anti-gay activists.
For now, it suffices to celebrate this landmark legislation toward which so many people worked. Those elsewhere who won the prize before us will perhaps forgive us if we try a new greeting for our city’s visitors: Welcome to the capital of marriage equality!